Cover for Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 's first DVD and Blu-ray release, known in Japan as Alchemist of Steel: Fullmetal Alchemist ( 鋼の錬金術師 フルメタルアルケミスト, Hagane no Renkinjutsushi: Furumetaru Arukemisuto), is the second independent adaptation developed by from the series. Worked as director, and as writer. The series follows the story of two alchemist brothers, and, who want to restore their bodies after a disastrous failed attempt to bring their mother back to life through alchemy. Unlike the first anime, which added original elements to the story, the second series follows the manga.
The series comprises a total of 64 episodes and four.The series premiered on April 5, 2009, on MBS-TBS's Sunday 5:30 pm anime timeblock, replacing. It received its English language premiere five days later on, with Japanese audio and English subtitles. Anime distributor streamed English subtitled episodes four days after the Japanese air dates on both its website and its channel. Funimation suspended streaming of the series for a few weeks in May following the accidental leak of an episode of from its servers before it had aired in Japan. All episodes were also available on American subscription service, showing 14 days after their original airing, as well as via Australia's. English dubbed episodes of the show started on American cable channel from February 13, 2010, onwards, as part of their Saturday anime block.began releasing the series in DVD and Blu-ray on August 26, 2009.
The first one contains two episodes and an original video animation (OVA). Three more OVAs were included in the fifth, ninth and thirteenth volumes alongside four episodes. Other volumes feature four episodes and no OVAs. A total of sixteen volumes were released, with the last one on November 24, 2010.
Funimation released the episodes on Blu-ray and DVD in five volumes, each of thirteen episodes on May 25, 2010.Brotherhood's music composer is. Ten pieces of were used in Brotherhood. The respective opening and ending themes for the first 14 episodes are ' by, and 'Uso' ( 嘘, lit. From episode 15-26, the respective opening and ending themes are ' by, and '. From episode 27-38, the respective opening and ending themes are 'Golden Time Lover' by, and 'Tsunaida Te' ( つないだ手, lit. 'Tied Hands'). From episode 39-50, the respective opening and ending themes are 'Period' by, and ' ( 瞬間センチメンタル, Shunkan Senchimentaru, lit.
'Sentimental Moment'). From episodes 51-62, the respective opening and ending themes are 'Rain' ( レイン, Rein) by Sid, and 'Ray of Light'. While episodes 63 and 64 do not use opening themes, they use 'Rain' and 'Hologram', respectively, for the endings. ^ Animage Editorial Staff (October 2008). 鋼の錬金術師 新シリーズ.
(in Japanese). Tokyo, Japan:. 364 (October 2008): 67. Retrieved 2008-08-20. February 9, 2010. Retrieved February 10, 2010.
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Movie
Retrieved 2009-02-27. Retrieved 2009-03-21.
Retrieved 2009-06-19. Anime News Network. Retrieved 2009-07-01.
Retrieved 2009-12-29. Straight from Japan: New subtitled episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood every Thursday @ 10:00 a.m.
Retrieved 2009-04-04. ^. Archived from on February 5, 2010. Retrieved February 5, 2010. ^ (in Japanese). Archived from on July 18, 2011.
Retrieved 2009-04-15. ^ (in Japanese). Archived from on July 18, 2011. Retrieved January 25, 2010. (in Japanese).
Retrieved December 21, 2010. (in Japanese). Retrieved December 21, 2010.
Retrieved August 31, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on July 18, 2011.
Retrieved 2009-04-15. (in Japanese). From the original on July 19, 2011. Retrieved October 14, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved June 17, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved June 17, 2009. (in Japanese).
Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved June 17, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved June 17, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08.
Retrieved June 17, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved June 17, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08.
Retrieved June 17, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved June 17, 2009. ^. Archived from on April 11, 2010. Retrieved April 11, 2010.
(in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08.
Retrieved June 17, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved June 17, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved June 14, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08.
Retrieved July 5, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08.
Retrieved July 5, 2009. ^. Archived from on May 17, 2010. Retrieved May 17, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on 2009-07-08. Retrieved July 5, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on August 14, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on August 14, 2009.
Retrieved July 5, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on August 14, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on August 14, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on August 14, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on October 20, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009. (in Japanese).
Archived from on October 20, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009. ^. Archived from on June 11, 2010. Retrieved June 11, 2010. (in Japanese).
Archived from on October 20, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on October 20, 2009.
Retrieved July 5, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on October 20, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009. (in Japanese).
Archived from on October 20, 2009. Retrieved July 5, 2009. June 29, 2010. Retrieved June 29, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on October 20, 2009.
Retrieved July 5, 2009. December 17, 2010. Retrieved December 18, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on October 29, 2009. Retrieved October 29, 2009. ^.
Archived from on December 27, 2010. Retrieved December 27, 2010. (in Japanese).
Archived from on October 29, 2009. Retrieved October 29, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on October 29, 2009. Retrieved November 1, 2009. (in Japanese).
Archived from on 2009-11-01. Retrieved November 30, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on November 8, 2009. Retrieved November 8, 2009. ^. Archived from on January 26, 2011.
Retrieved January 26, 2011. (in Japanese).
Archived from on November 24, 2009. Retrieved November 24, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on November 24, 2009. Retrieved November 24, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on November 29, 2009. Retrieved November 29, 2009. ^.
Archived from on March 4, 2011. Retrieved March 4, 2011. (in Japanese). Archived from on December 8, 2009.
Retrieved December 6, 2009. ^. Archived from on April 2, 2011. Retrieved April 2, 2011. (in Japanese). Archived from on December 14, 2009.
Retrieved December 14, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on December 21, 2009. Retrieved December 14, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on January 6, 2009.
Retrieved January 6, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on January 16, 2009.
Retrieved January 6, 2009. (in Japanese).
Archived from on January 20, 2009. Retrieved January 20, 2009.
(in Japanese). Archived from on January 25, 2009. Retrieved January 25, 2009. (in Japanese). Archived from on January 31, 2010. Retrieved January 31, 2010.
^. Archived from on May 8, 2011. Retrieved April 29, 2011.
(in Japanese). Archived from on February 9, 2010. Retrieved February 9, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on February 14, 2010. Retrieved February 14, 2010. (in Japanese).
Archived from on February 22, 2010. Retrieved February 22, 2010. (in Japanese).
Archived from on March 1, 2010. Retrieved March 1, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on March 7, 2010. Retrieved March 7, 2010. (in Japanese).
Archived from on March 17, 2010. Retrieved March 15, 2010. ^.
Archived from on June 14, 2011. Retrieved May 14, 2011. (in Japanese). Archived from on March 24, 2010. Retrieved March 22, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on April 2, 2010.
Retrieved March 29, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on April 5, 2010.
Retrieved April 5, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on April 11, 2010. Retrieved April 11, 2010.
^. Archived from on June 28, 2011. Retrieved June 27, 2011. (in Japanese). Archived from on April 22, 2010. Retrieved April 22, 2010.
(in Japanese). Archived from on April 25, 2010. Retrieved April 25, 2010. (in Japanese).
Archived from on May 5, 2010. Retrieved May 5, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on May 17, 2010.
Retrieved May 9, 2010. Graphic workshop professional v3.0a40. ^. Archived from on June 28, 2011. Retrieved August 28, 2011. (in Japanese).
Archived from on May 17, 2010. Retrieved May 17, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on May 23, 2010.
Retrieved May 23, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on June 1, 2010. Retrieved June 1, 2010. (in Japanese). Archived from on June 7, 2010. Retrieved June 7, 2010.
(in Japanese). Archived from on June 12, 2010.
Retrieved June 12, 2010. ^. Archived from on September 12, 2011. Retrieved August 28, 2011.
(in Japanese). Archived from on June 23, 2010.
Retrieved June 23, 2010. (in Japanese). Retrieved July 4, 2010. ^. Anime News Network. February 28, 2012.
Retrieved March 1, 2012.External links.
Synopsis 'In order for something to be obtained, something of equal value must be lost.' Alchemy is bound by this Law of Equivalent Exchange—something the young brothers Edward and Alphonse Elric only realize after attempting human transmutation: the one forbidden act of alchemy. They pay a terrible price for their transgression—Edward loses his left leg, Alphonse his physical body. It is only by the desperate sacrifice of Edward's right arm that he is able to affix Alphonse's soul to a suit of armor.
Devastated and alone, it is the hope that they would both eventually return to their original bodies that gives Edward the inspiration to obtain metal limbs called 'automail' and become a state alchemist, the Fullmetal Alchemist.Three years of searching later, the brothers seek the Philosopher's Stone, a mythical relic that allows an alchemist to overcome the Law of Equivalent Exchange. Even with military allies Colonel Roy Mustang, Lieutenant Riza Hawkeye, and Lieutenant Colonel Maes Hughes on their side, the brothers find themselves caught up in a nationwide conspiracy that leads them not only to the true nature of the elusive Philosopher's Stone, but their country's murky history as well. In between finding a serial killer and racing against time, Edward and Alphonse must ask themselves if what they are doing will make them human again. Or take away their humanity.Written by MAL Rewrite. Overall10Story10Animation9Sound9Character10Enjoyment10First of all, I have seen the original FMA and although it was very popular and original, the pacing and conclusion did not sit too well with me. Brotherhood is meant to be a remake of the original, this time sticking to the manga all the way through, but there were people who thought it would spoil the franchise.
That myth should be dispelled, as there's only one word to describe this series - EPIC.I admit that as I've seen the original and read the manga, the pacing of Brotherhood seems to start off being VERY fast (I finally got used to the pacing afterwatching the first fifteen eps or so). Events that took up half a volume of the manga and had spread though a few episodes of the original anime were now shown in just a single episode. However, after trying to look at it from the perspective of someone who's new to FMA (not comparing it to the manga nor the original), I believe that the pacing works and it manages to tell an intriguing story effectively with little confusion. The plot is full of clever ideas and unpredictable twists that link various parts of the story together. By the final episode, all loose ends are neatly tied up and what's left is a hugely satisfying epilogue.The animation in FMA Brotherhood is crisp and very well done (although it does sometimes dip a bit in quality). Compared to the original FMA it's a bit simpler but that's just because the original set a very high standard to follow.
The facial emotions of the characters are also perfectly presented. The action scenes are brilliant and VERY well animated, with a variety of alchemy techniques and other talents being displayed nearly every episode.
The various battles are consistently exciting to watch, but somehow get even better towards the end of the series.The voice acting is of an excellent and consistent quality, and I think that pretty much all the characters have voice actors which suit their personalities. The majority of the openings/endings are a pleasure to watch due to fantastic animated sequences and theme songs. The background music which play during the episodes usually fit very well with the situation, although some tracks seem to be overused a little at first.
This becomes less of a problem as the series progresses, with plenty of new music being introduced to support the story as it reaches the finale.Moving on to the characters (best thing about this series), the original FMA focussed mainly on Ed and Al and on their struggles to regain their bodies, whereas Brotherhood also explores other characters to great detail at the same time. The majority of the spotlight is still on the two brothers, but it highlights their interactions with new characters which were not present in the original anime.
New characters include a group of people from Xing (a neighbouring country), another person from the Armstrong family (who I think has become one of the coolest members of the supporting cast), and a new main antagonist. For me, the Xingese characters in particular (Ling Yao and Mei Chang among others) provide a new dimension to the FMA world, by showing us a different culture to the militaristic one we're familiar with.
I think the new antagonist is an improvement on the original FMA, as this person has a much stronger and clever link to the Elric brothers' father. Returning characters from the original FMA, such as Mustang and Scar, are much more awesome and developed due to the fact that Brotherhood is 100% faithful to the manga. Plus, Winry Rockbell now has a much more active role in the story. I can say for sure that this anime has one of the best main/supporting casts I've ever seen, and you'd probably find it difficult to label any of the recurring characters (whether they are good or evil) as being either boring or unnecessary in terms of the storyline.One of the many good things about this series is that there has been absolutely no filler at all (yes, I'm thinking of Naruto, Inuyasha, etc), which prevents the story from losing momentum. All the episodes are concise and every scene is important as part of the huge plot.
The dialogue fully explains everything and is straight to the point. As multiple characters are explored there are lots of side stories, but these are all perfectly intertwined with the main story of the Elric brothers and more often than not directly influence their journey too. Like most anime series, there are things from the manga which have been left out, but these are usually just restricted to comedy moments. There has been one episode which shows a lot of flashbacks of events so far, but that's forgiven as it shows the most epic moments of the series, and also provided us with some history on the father of the Elric brothers.FMA Brotherhood will be sorely missed now that it's finished. It is excellent in every aspect and has very little, if anything, that can be called a flaw (maybe rushed character development at first due to the fast pacing, but this quickly subsides).
Each episode feels like it's too short, a testimony to how much it draws you in to the story and characters. There are moments which leave you smiling, laughing, sad and simply amazed. Try this anime, it's recommended for absolutely everyone, to newcomers and to those familiar with Fullmetal Alchemist. Overall9Story8Animation9Sound9Character9Enjoyment9Adaptations have long been a thorn in the side of anime viewers, but not because they are inherently bad. Overall7Story8Animation8Sound10Character6Enjoyment7Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood gets an immense amount of praise in the MAL community, is the #1 ranked show and is constantly referred to as a masterpiece and the greatest show ever created. I've seen many fans preach about how 'it lives up to the hype' and 'can never receive too much praise'. Now this is just the opinion of one guy.
I'm certainly not the law of the land or anything. However, I personally feel as though calling FMA:B a masterpiece and the champion of all shows is a bit of a stretch.
That's not to say that I didn't enjoy it or that itisn't a very solid addition to the ranks of notable shows; I really would like to preface this review by saying that I believe that FMA:B is a very good show and I wouldn't be nearly as harsh on it if it weren't for the God status the show has attained in America. I would happily remand 'greatest show ever made' to 'greatest long-running shonen ever made if you haven't seen the 2011 Hunter X Hunter'I'm not a huge fan of the MAL categorical rating system, as I've mentioned in some of my previous reviews. I oftentimes outright ignore it. However, looking at the categories right now, I feel as though this is one instance where I can use it to talk about everything I want to so I'm going to use it.STORY: 8The FMA:B plot and world-building are some of its strongest aspects. The world that it creates is an immersive, full-feeling thing with many animate pieces that move even when you aren't looking at them. It's an extremely creative world as well, adopting its own set of universal laws including alchemy through equivalent exchange, mind-body duality and its own interpretation of a higher power, and it sticks by these laws. Never once does the story contradict its own rules, instead using them in creative ways to build off of each other.
The plot is also one of the most engaging parts of the show, unveiling itself at just the right pace to keep you interested whilst still keeping a few major cards to play at the very end. The pieces fall into place in a way that is satisfying because it simultaneously mind-blowing and obvious, and that's one of the marks of strong storytelling.While the FMA:B story is certainly one of the best I've seen, I find that I have to withhold my 10 score here on the grounds that its incredible direction and creativity are marred by some detrimental weaknesses. First of all, the exposition is handled extremely poorly.
Overall7Story8Animation8Sound8Character8Enjoyment8Overview:FMA Brotherhood is an anime that needs no introduction. This is the highest rated anime on all of MAL. This is the anime that the current generation of anime fans holds above all others as the greatest single anime EVER made!
In the following paragraphs, I will be reviewing this legendary series and discussing whether or not it truly deserves this title.SPOILERS for both Brotherhood and 2003 FMA!!!!Plot:The plot takes place in the country of Armestris, which is basically like an alternate WW2 Germany. It is constantly at war for reasons that are less than just and is ruled by a rather nefarious government.What makes this world special is that alchemy is the primary science instead of the much less fun and flashy science of our own reality. Alchemy allows practitioners to transmute material into other useful material, and basically do all kinds of awesome stuff! Our heroes are the Elric brothers, who wish to find the legendary Philosopher's Stone and gain back their original bodies that they lost in a forbidden alchemy ritual gone horribly wrong. In order to search for the stone, they join the military.
Unfortunately this means they have to serve under a rather evil government and face strong moral dilemmas. The Elric brothers don't wish to take part in the government's genocidal campaigns, but they need the military in order to accomplish their own personal goals. Of course, things are a bit more complicated by the fact that many in the military are actually good people and are either unaware of just how bad the government is, or feel remorse for their crimes and wish to change the government. This is refreshing for a shonen series in which 'good and evil' is too often clear cut. We have all seen Hollywood movies where the German Army is filled with nothing but pure evil monsters with zero humanity. As a side note, eventually Hollywood got MUCH better with treating the Germans this way. Thanks to us ethnic Germans making up 40% of the US population, but Hollywood STILL treats the Russians and certain other groups this way!Eventually, the Elric brothers uncover the frightening truth that the real leader behind the government is an ancient evil being called 'Father' who uses his homunculus minions to due his bidding and wishes for ultimate knowledge and power!
The Elric brothers also make many allies on their adventures including Scar, the Xingese, and Hohenheim, who all contribute in the fight against Father. The plot ultimately concludes with a very happy ending, which pleased fans far more than the bittersweet ending of the 2003 anime. It should also be noted that unlike the plot of the 2003 anime, FMA Brotherhood mostly stays faithful the Hiromu Arakawa's original manga.Differences between 2003 FMA and Brotherhood:Although there are many differences in the plot which I will get to, the most immediately obvious difference is in the tone of the series' narrative. The 2003 FMA has a VERY dark and somber tone throughout the series, which makes it really stand out as the oddball of the shonen world. FMA Brotherhood has tragic moments, but they are balanced out with zany comedy, more happy endings, and less emotional suffering in general.
The tone in Brotherhood actually feels like you are watching a shonen anime like Naruto or One Piece. You know going in that there will be sad parts, but all will turn out well in the end. FMA 2003 feels closer to watching Berserk than it does to watching Naruto or One Piece!
Whether a viewer prefers lighthearted shonen or brooding seinen is a matter of taste, but let us take a look at the subject matter being dealt with in this series. In both the 2003 FMA and Brotherhood, this is a series about German soldiers serving a genocidal regime and ultimately having to rebel against the government and try atone for their crimes. Does that sound like something that should be a fun, zany comedy? 'It is almost certain that we will fail. But how will future history judge the German people if not even a handful of men had the courage to put an end to that criminal?' - Henning Von Tresckow.
I can ASSURE you he didn't tell a stupid joke 20 seconds afterwards so that his listeners wouldn't feel sad about the deaths of 17 million civilians murdered by the Nazis as 'untermenschen'. Was the movie Das Boot a fun comedy? Have you ever wondered why that is? The reason is that making a movie or series about German soldiers reflecting on mass genocide into a delightful romp is fucking stupid as hell! To think that people on MAL accuse Elfen Lied of having bad tone whiplash. FMA Brotherhood thematically achieves a mood whiplash other anime can only dream of.Now we get to characters and plot differences.
Firstly, lets talk about everyone's favorite FMA character, Roy Mustang. In FMA 2003, Roy is the one who murdered Winry's parents instead of Scar. Roy is also MUCH more affected by his guilt for having murdered hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians in the name of an evil government. In 2003 FMA, Roy actually tries to kill himself in a state of deep depression, but Hughes stops him and instead inspires him to live, so that one day he can overthrow and lead the government.
Roy actually manages to kill Fuhrer Bradley and do what he had dreamed of for so long. However, he is too overwhelmed by the emotional stress to simply stay in the military and take a role of leadership like he does in Brotherhood. Roy retires to a simple life with Hawkeye instead and only uses his alchemy again in the movie Conquerors of Shamballa to save the people of Central. Roy is a MUCH more empathetic and truly human character in the original 2003 series.
He is actually, truly effected by guilt and stress the way a real person that isn't a total sociopath would be. He doesn't just feel kind of bad for about 5 minutes, then move on. 'I killed those people under orders, I don't have to REALLY feel too bad about it.' If the point is to make Roy a true military hero that reveals the full horrors of war and shows how even good men will commit evil deeds under orders, then the 2003 anime accomplishes this a LOT better than Brotherhood did!Now let's look at the Arab anti-hero Scar.
In both series, Scar is a survivor of the Ishvalan genocide who is consumed with the desire for vengeance against the State Alchemists that slaughtered his people. In both series, Scar has an elder brother who violated Scar's Ishvalan religion and practiced alchemy, ultimately saving his life and giving him his special arm. However, in the 2003 anime we learn that Scar's brother violated a FAR more sacred law and tried to resurrect his dead lover with alchemy.
This was of course a miserable failure that drove his brother mad with grief and furthered Scar's hatred of alchemy. This works better in terms of narrative, because it gives Scar even more reason to hate alchemy as violently as he does and view it as 'false'. It also better explains why Scar sympathized with Edward Elric, because he could tell he had lost his limbs in a human transmutation and was reminded of his own brother. In terms of objective 'writing 101' and constructing a narrative, this extra back story from the 2003 anime was brilliant and felt far more complete than Brotherhood. Scar's end is also WAY better in the original 2003 anime.
In Brotherhood, Scar fights his ultimate battle against Wrath, who was only the 3rd strongest homunculi, not the real mastermind behind the Ishvalan genocide, and had no real connection to Scar since they had never met. In the 2003 series, Scar fights his ultimate battle against the pure evil State Alchemist Zolf Kimblee, who murdered his brother and gave him his namesake scar. Which of these makes sense in terms of basic storytelling? Having a character's big fight be against a personal opponent where the struggle actually MEANS something, or have the fight be against a barely connected random character? It is sad that Scar has to die in the 2003 series, but his death is a heroic one and ultimately a much better written conclusion to his story.
In Brotherhood, Scar somehow survives in order for a happier ending and we get a quick cameo of him working to rebuild Ishval. Scar is a flawed anti-hero consumed with a desire for revenge. In the original series, his tragic and heroic death makes the audience care a LOT more about him than Brotherhood does. Would it have been good storytelling in Lord of the Rings if Boromir for some reason survived, then we get a quick 2 sentences about how he is living happily in Gondor after the war? That would be really stupid and Tolkien being a good writer, realized that and gave Boromir a heroic death of penance that better closed his story.There are WAY too many examples, so we will make our final one a comparison between Dante and Father.
How can I even compare them? You are probably thinking right now. 'Dante is just a forgettable Filler Villain and Father is one of the greatest villains in anime history!' The truth is that Father.isn't actually a very good villain. Remember that this is a story about an alternate WW2 Germany and a group of soldiers fighting against an evil government following a massive genocide. Adolf Hitler was not a nice man, but he WAS a human being. Dante is powerful, but ultimately just an ordinary human sociopath who wishes to sacrifice countless people she views as inferior to guarantee her own Godhood and immortality.
I think that sounds a LOT closer to Hitler than a fucking ink blot genie from Ancient Persia looking for ultimate knowledge. If you are going to tell a story with OBVIOUS real world parallels, then STAY CONSISTENT! Government atrocities and genocides happen due to ordinary human leaders with extremely selfish desires, NOT evil genies! The Holocaust, Cambodian Genocide, Rwandan Genocide, and Armenian Genocide were not caused by Mr.
Popo!!!Animation:FMA Brotherhood is a very well animated series and admittedly does look better in most places than the 2003 original. Is the animation enough to give it the title of greatest of all time? No.Soundtrack:The soundtrack for FMA Brotherhood is once again quite solid, but isn't even as good as the 2003 FMA OST, let alone worthy of the greatest of all time title! Just compare the main theme from the Brotherhood OST to the main theme Bratja from 2003 FMA.
The main theme for Brotherhood is a fairly bland orchestral piece with some ominous chanting that sounds like a throw away extra from the Hellsing Ultimate soundtrack. The main theme from the 2003 FMA is a heartbreaking, beautiful song about an elder brother asking forgiveness from his younger brother. Bratja is WAY better than anything in Brotherhood without question! Compare the first opening theme of Brotherhood to the 1st opening of the 2003 series. The 2003 series has Ready Steady Go, one of the greatest openings in the history of anime.
Brotherhood has an extremely forgettable opening that wouldn't rank in the top 500 anime openings.Overall:FMA Brotherhood is a good anime overall, but it is ONLY a good anime. It isn't anywhere NEAR the greatest anime ever made! It is actually vastly inferior to the original 2003 FMA and even that wasn't the single greatest anime of all time, although a MUCH better candidate than Brotherhood. Of course the title of G.O.A.T.
Is a highly subjective and debatable matter, but there isn't a single category where Brotherhood REALLY outshines its competitors. Some people say Legend of the Galactic Heroes is the greatest of all time. I'm not going to say that LOTGH is an absolutely flawless work, because it isn't.
However, it actually stays consistent in its tone with the heavy ideas and themes it presents. Brotherhood does not. Brotherhood is WAY closer to Elfen Lied than LOTGH in terms of keeping a consistent tone to respect very dark and serious subject matters. LOTGH has an absolutely EPIC scope with hundreds of well written characters, maybe the most intricate politics in all of anime, and gets viewers to really think about real world problems and issues in terms of government, better than any other anime ever made. In other words, LOTGH actually DOES have areas where it clearly outshines its peers and therefore has a far more legitimate claim to the throne.
Cowboy Bebop has almost without question the greatest original OST in anime history, is more accessible to non-anime fans than any other anime, and is an absolute blast from beginning to end. Once again, it has areas where it is clearly the best, so a more legitimate claim. Name just ONE thing that Brotherhood is the best at? Most tearjerking?
Best written? Not even close. Most philosophical and complex? Best soundtrack? It is solid around the board, but it isn't actually truly great at anything!
I would therefore argue that Brotherhood is NOT the greatest of all time, is INSANELY overrated, and you are honestly much better off watching the 2003 FMA. I'm sorry if this review hurt any feelings. My job as a critic is to say what needs to be said.